Objective
1-->1, 5, 12, 14, 15, 16--->All of these statements deal with the writing
process.
Objective
2---> 7, 8, 11, 17--->These statements deal with analysis. *I also believe
that 1 can be here also.
Objective
3---> 2, 4, 6, 17, 19--->These statements pertain to research.
Objective
4---> 10,13--->Both of these statements talk about presentations.
Objective
5---> 3,9--->Both of these statements relate to discussions.
Statement
1: practice--->"I...revise" A statement about an individual's revision
tactics.
Statement
2: feeling--->"I am confident" This statement is about an individual's
confidence in conducting research.
Statement
3: knowledge--->"I know..." This statement either confirms or denies an
individual's ability to make connections.
Statement
4: practice/knowledge--->"I am able to use textual analysis..." Practice and
knowledge because the individual most be able to use textual analysis.
Statement
5: practice--->"When I revise..." Another statement about an individual's
writing process.
Statement
6: practice/knowledge--->"I am able to use discourse analysis..." same as
4
Statement
7: practice--->"I use writing..."A statement about the use of writing.
Statement
8: feeling--->"I feel..." An individuals feeling about starting a
discussion.
Statement
9: knowledge--->"I know..." The individual knows how to.
Statement
10: feeling--->"I am comfortable..." Another feeling statement.
Statement
11: practice/knowledge--->"I am able to interpret..." Both because they need
experience and knowledge to perform the actions in the statement.
Statement
12: practice--->"When I revise..." Another statement about the writing
process.
Statement
13: practice/knowledge--->"I have given a presentation..." Both again.
Statement
14: practice--->"When I revise..." Another writing process statement.
Statement
15: practice--->"I typically brainstorm..." Another writing process
statement.
What
definition(s) of "writing" and "learning" is assumed by this
survey? Are
those definitions a good match for the definitions assumed by the student
learning outcomes? Are
they a good match for the way the students taking the survey will define writing
and learning?
How
might you change this survey so that it could provide a more accurate reflection
of what students learn in this program? List your suggestions.
The
"Writing" statements used in this survey focus their attention on the writing
process. According to the survey, "Learning" pertains to literature analysis
and literary research.
Matching
the questions to the statements:
I
agree that most of these statements fit the survey; however, I feel that there
are some statements that should be re-worded or revised for the students taking
the survey.
Statement 2: I am confident...
Statement 8: I feel comfortable...
Statement 10: I am comfortable...
The
modifiers used in these sentences take away from the statement. For example,
statement 10 says, "I feelcomfortable giving presentations." However, the
objective states that, "students will demonstrate ability to give
acompelling oral presentation." I, for one, am not comfortable giving
presentations, but I can give one. In this case, I would disagree with the
statement. Perhaps, the statement should be, "I am able to give a
presentation."
Statement 12: "When I revise my first draft, I spend most of my time on
grammatical issues."
I
am guessing that this statement falls within the first objective: Students will
produce essays through a series of drafts that include exploratory writing and
talk, as well as revisions that include addition, deletion, substitution and
rearrangement. However, after reading this goals, I don't see "grammatical
issues" anywhere within the objective.
I
also believe that the survey needs some type of organization (unless that was
the surveyors intentions). The survey jumps from the writing process to
research to presentations, which takes away the surveyors focus. If there was
organization within the survey, the surveyor could give their full attention to
one aspect (e.i. writing process) before moving onto another topic.